mater monstrorum
  • Home
  • Site Categories
    • Comprehensible Input
    • ESOL >
      • ESOL Quick links
    • Expand Your Classics
    • Latin Snail Mail
    • Miriam's Quick Picks
    • PBP/Stepping Into CI >
      • Stepping into CI
      • Pomegranate Beginnings Blog
    • Social Justice
    • Special Education
    • Teaching and COVID
    • Technology
  • Originals
    • Lesson Plans
    • Original Audio Stories
    • Original Characters
    • Original Songs
    • Pondering Petronius
  • Publications
    • Published Novellas
    • Professional Publications
    • Presentations
  • Announcements
  • About me
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Site Categories
    • Comprehensible Input
    • ESOL >
      • ESOL Quick links
    • Expand Your Classics
    • Latin Snail Mail
    • Miriam's Quick Picks
    • PBP/Stepping Into CI >
      • Stepping into CI
      • Pomegranate Beginnings Blog
    • Social Justice
    • Special Education
    • Teaching and COVID
    • Technology
  • Originals
    • Lesson Plans
    • Original Audio Stories
    • Original Characters
    • Original Songs
    • Pondering Petronius
  • Publications
    • Published Novellas
    • Professional Publications
    • Presentations
  • Announcements
  • About me
    • Contact
Books to Read
Resources for Action
Blogs and Articles to Read
Social Media to Follow
Audio to Listen to and Videos to watch

Listen First

6/21/2022

0 Comments

 
A note: Please use these practices with the best intentions. Students can see through us when we lie or foster practices that do not include compassion. If we aren't coming from a good place we (at best) foster a distant relationship with students and (at worst) cause trauma and harm to our students.

I have long been on a journey towards a compassionate classroom and while I do my best to always answer with compassion I don't know that's it is a journey without an end. Each year, each month, week, and day provide new opportunities for me to re-establish compassionate norms and choose compassion for myself, my colleagues, and my students. To be clear, answering with compassion (much like gentle parenting) is not without boundaries or consequences, but it works with natural consequences and clear understanding of boundaries. 

There are a lot of posts on these topics, but I want to highlight a few:
  • Bob Patrick's post on community in the classroom
  • My reflection on Bob's No Fail Classroom
  • The blog: The Inclusive Latin Classroom
Today I want to touch on a practice I've been subconsciously cultivating the past few years: Listen First. It sounds simple, but I think there is a push in the teacher/student relationship (especially with all that we have to do) to skip this step and move on to the action piece of whatever situation arises. Ultimately, however, I think this sets us and our students up for failure. 

I've been watching a lot of gentle parenting TikToks after they started showing up on my FYP and I quickly realised how in line they were with my own thinking. My parents did a form of this when I was a child, but it didn't have a name and it wasn't as popular as it is now. One thing that stood out to me is something I've been as vocal as I can be about since earning my Special Education degree. Behaviour is an attempt at communication. When students behave in certain ways they are trying to tell us what they need and they are using coping mechanisms that they've learned work through the various situations in their lives. Note: I am NOT trying to dig at any single person who is a teacher or parent. Once we understand that concept, we realise that in order to do anything, we must understand the need that is being communicated. 

The longer I teach the more I realise that listening is always the first step with students. I have a policy that if a student is in crisis and needs me, I will do my best to help them as I can. This does put added pressure on me, but it also doesn't put me in a place where I have to fix everything. Here are some general examples of what this might look like. This is not exhaustive and not every option fits every instance
  • A student is having a panic attack
    • I share a grounding technique I use
    • I allow them time to calm down in a safe space
    • I have a deal with a neighbour teacher that students can go in there (they often have a quieter room) to calm down
  • A student hasn't eaten all day
    • I have a drawer of snacks that I offer. They include applesauce, seaweed chips, and protein bars (or whatever I have extra of at home)
  • A student is having an awful day for (insert reason)
    • "handle with care"
    • grab a stuffie for comfort
    • get extended time on an assignment
    • be allowed to actively listen but not vocally participate for the day
  • A student has a tantrum in class (yes, it happens at high school too)
    • We step outside to cool down
    • I ask unrelated questions to refocus the student
    • The student and I come up with a plan to refocus and meet the basic needs and requirements for the day
When we listen first, we can learn the unmet need and respond appropriately. Here are some questions I either consider myself or I ask students directly when listening first. N.B. Always make sure your students know that (1) you are imperfect and do the best you can (2) are coming from a compassionate place, and (3) are a mandatory reporter and that you have to report some things. If you do need to report something, please please please tell the student who experienced it before you report it so they aren't caught off guard.​
  1. Basic Needs
    1. Have you eaten today?
    2. How much sleep did you get?
    3. Have you been outside today?
    4. How is your anxiety today?
    5. Do you have what you need for class? (if the answer is no.... provide the supply with no judgement or shame)
  2. (if a student is reacting towards me in a highly negative way) Have I offended or hurt you? I would like to correct that.
  3. What are you feeling right now?
    1. Physically
    2. Emotionally
  4. Why do you think that? What has led you to this conclusion? (take the response without judgement)
  5. If you could have one thing right now what would it be?
  6. Do you have a friend or trusted adult you can speak to? 
  7. Would you like to go to the counselor?
  8. What do you need from me right now?
    1. N.B. Sometimes students will ask for a hug. If you are not comfortable with that, offer an alternative.
  9. Regarding a specific incident (even if they don't want to tell you what happened, you can find out how close in time and space this happened)
    1. Did this happen just now? Earlier today? This week?
    2. Did this happen in my classroom? 
    3. Is this happening digitally?
    4. Do you want me to call/email your parent/guardian/Assistant principal/counselor/etc. 
    5. How can I support you?
0 Comments

Comprehensible Input and Social Justice (6)

6/29/2020

0 Comments

 
This is the final piece of this 6 part series. If you haven't, please go and read parts 1-5 first. They are on the first five principles of the Comprehension Hypothesis: Acquisition and Learning, the Natural Order Hypothesis, the monitor principle, the input hypothesis, the affective filter, and their role in social justice in the classroom. 
Acquisition and Learning
The natural order hypothesis
The monitor principle
The input hypothesis
the affective filter

The Compelling Hypothesis

Ideally we all want our students to be interested in what we are saying, but just like we all have different tastes in foods, books, and music, so will the reaction vary as to how our students react to us. For a long time, teachers have relied on the idea of "motivation" as to how well students react to information. I hear a lot of times that "if students were just motivated.... X would happen", but that's not how things work. While "compelling" is not  necessarily required to acquire language (simply put), it is required for fully successful SLA (Krashen, 2011; Patrick, 2019). When input is compelling, there is not need for "motivation" because one is so drawn in that they "forget" they are actually acquiring language and enter what Krashen (2011) calls a state of flow (Krashen, 2011). You don't have to want to improve, it will just happen because you find the material so compelling; the resulting progress may even be completely unexpected (Krashen, 2011). Patrick (2019) notes the immediate connection between this hypothesis and the affective filter, "choice may be one way of lowering the affective filter and inviting students into the understandable input that we have planned for them - if our planning has taken [student choices] into consideration" (Patrick, 2019, p. 42). This is why I said yesterday that the compelling input and affective filter principles are the most important, in my opinion, when it comes to being a teacher who truly understands and employs CI principles. Everything we do must be run through a CI filter. Every decision we make must be comprehensible, allow natural order, avoid the monitor until they are ready, provide input, lower the affective filter, and be compelling. 

If that list overwhelmed you, I get it. It can be a lot and no one is perfect. We adjust. In the next two sections, I am going to reflect myself on the questions I posed yesterday and then show how I might consider the 6 principles of CI when looking at a topic often covered in Latin classes. I hope you can see how this principle and all 6, when fully understood and applied, provide a classroom where students are valued and respected for who they are and included as people who belong in the classroom with me. 

Before I do. Thank you for coming with me on this journey. While my daily blogging pauses here for now, the conversation isn't over. I would love to consider a follow up post (or a few) addressing any specifics, questions, or ideas we share in our community. There has already been great discussion on various social medias about this. I'd like to see more. 

Reflection - Discussion

  1. Are my students welcome in my room or do they belong in this classroom? I say this to parents every parent night. You students are not welcome in my room. They belong in this classroom. Using "welcome" in this context means, "you are in my space. I'm happy you are here, but you must abide by my roles and expectations". "Belong" in this context means, "Hello! This is a space we share together. You belong here as the person you are, no strings attached."
  2. What do I do to marry my area of expertise and interest with the passions of the students who are in, or want to be in my room? For me, this is an ongoing conversation with my students. I want to know what things they like, what they don't like, what is helpful, and what isn't... and why. What I often find is that if I tweak something slightly, the compelling factor is increased. Regarding content, please see the next section for some detail. 
  3. What do I do to highlight and lift up voices of indigenous people, black people, people of colour in texts/discussions/history/culture/etc? Everything I possibly can. Here's the thing. Representation MATTERS. How can we expect anything to be compelling or comprehensible if students never see themselves in our classroom? Our culture, our textbooks, resources, etc. are already geared to serve white norms. We have to work to change that. So, every chance we get, we lift up BIPOC voices. We put posters up, choose artwork we share consciously. We stop whitewashing stories and point out when our books do it. We do everything we possibly can.  
  4. How do I talk about slavery, colonialism, imperialism, and racism in my classroom? We start by listening. Do some reading and look into the real history of things. We change our languages. Latin teachers.... STOP, if you are, saying that servus means servant. It means slave. STOP saying that slaves might be "treated well" or that slave owners were "kind". STOP using the word dominus or domina to refer to you as their teacher. Instead, call the Romans colonisers. Call them murderers, kidnappers, etc. Same thing when it comes to the English, the Spanish, the Americans etc. Clarify that while people like the Irish, Scottish, Germans, etc. were persecuted for things like language, religion, and culture, they were NOT persecuted for their skin colour. Do the reading and research and clear up your own misconceptions of history and don't perpetuate the system. 
  5. What supports to I regularly use to support learners of all types in my room? In my classroom, I use a visual schedule, provide audio readings of texts, provide stuffed animals and fidget toys, allow the use of languages other than English for many types of work, allow students to draw, write, act, build, etc., make things in large print, with unique fonts, and colours, as needed, provide multiple versions of a test that employ various types of organisation (boxes or tables for those who need them), fonts, text size, etc., and work to allow things like small group instruction or small group testing wherever I can. I don't think this list is exhaustive, and I hope it isn't, but I also know I'm not perfect. I can and continue to try to do better. 
  6. Can my students see themselves in every aspect of what we do (the content, the context, the means, the physical space, etc)? I hope so, but I am going to keep trying. In my classroom, I have posters from Teaching Tolerance that include BIPOC, LGBTQIA+, immigrant, and other voices. When I choose artwork, I try to vary it up and include artwork that looks like my students. I provide options for seating, engaging, input, and expression. If you'd like more, take a look at this presentation. Am I perfect? No. Am I going to stop trying? No. 
  7. Do I run every decision I make for my students through the CI test (if you will)? Is it comprehensible, caring, and compelling (credit to Rachel Ash for the three Cs)? See below. 
  8. Do I know why a student does poorly on an activity/assessment? What am I doing to support them towards their goals? Yes and No. If I don't know why a student did poorly, I am going to ask and accept their answer, whatever it is. Then we will come up with a plan. It may require more instruction/input. It may require a new format or more time. Whatever it is, we'll work it out together.   
  9. Am I providing multiple means of engagement, representation, and expression (UDL)? As often as I can. Engagement is how students work with the material, representation is how the material is presented, and expression is how students show progress (put very simply). See my previous post for more. 
  10. and... How do I know?I work to build trust first through reality pedagogy and, if needed, employ a cogen. As we work to build this community together, the conversations start to happen and students feel comfortable telling me. 

A quick work through

Let's look at a common topic taught in Latin classes, and one I previously discussed: the house and home. Here are some quick suggestions for how I consider the three CCCs of CI and the six principles. This is not exhaustive. Please, if you'd like, reach out and let's talk more!
  1. Comprehensible - I consider what words are already acquired, what words are needed, and what words they've asked for. I ensure that I truly understand the context of each word so that I can provide real comprehensible input that is appropriate and anti-racist. We engage in discussion of the Romans, current events, and our own lives. I provide multiple ways of understanding these words: drawing, definitions, derivatives, and others. We look at a variety of homes in a variety of contexts: ancient and modern.
  2. Natural Order - If students do poorly on an activity or assessment, I reassess, regularly. I am always looking at what students are showing me. If a student has never greeted me in Latin before and starts... you best believe I'm taking a grade! I try to judge student work on their own progress rather than against others. I try not to shame students for asking the same question repeatedly. This is hard for me, but it is something I am working on. 
  3. Monitor - If they haven't asked for it, I don't need to explain it. I don't correct them if they choose to communicate with me. If I don't understand, I ask for clarification.
  4. Input - My job is providing input. They will give output when they are ready. I can provide some scripted things to students who need them, but I try to never force output if they aren't ready. Some things you can provide that allow students to communicate in their own time: ASL, gestures, choices, yes and no questions, communication cards
  5. Affective Filter - I always ask myself: who is represented in these stories, this vocabulary, these images? When I share student work, am I only sharing white imagery? Am I being equitable when I talk about the "house" or am I only showing wealthy houses, talking about slave owners in Rome, etc. And... how do I talk about those from lower socioeconomic status and the places they call home? 
  6. Compelling - What do students want to talk about? If they want to talk about themselves, we may look at examples of Roman houses, but then we'll design or share our own. If they want to talk about socioeconomic status in Rome, we'll do it. I can teach the same vocab, the same culture, the same history in ways that are accurate and​ compelling.  

References

Krashen, S. (2011). The compelling (not just interesting) input hypothesis. The English Connection (KOTESOL), 15, (3). Retrieved from: 
​
http://sdkrashen.com/content/articles/the_compelling_(not_just_interesting)_input_hyothesis.pdf

Patrick, R. (2019). Comprehensible Input and Krashen's theory. 
Journal of Classics Teaching, 20(39), 37-44. doi:10.1017/S2058631019000060
0 Comments

Comprehensible Input and Social Justice (4)

6/27/2020

0 Comments

 
This is part 4 in a 6 part series. If you haven't, please go and read parts 1-3 first. They are on the first two principle of the Comprehension Hypothesis: Acquisition and Learning, the Natural Order Hypothesis, the monitor principle, and their role in social justice in the classroom. 
Acquisition and Learning
The Natural Order Hypothesis
The Monitor Principle

The Input Hypothesis

The input hypothesis is commonly referred to as the i+1 hypothesis. It states that we acquire language when we receive understandable input that is just outside of what we have already acquired (Krashen, 1983). This is not to be confused with forced output or immersion classes (Patrick, 2019). There is a distinct difference. Further, traditional grammar-translation teachers can also be guilty of this by forcing translation, exposure and engagement with grammar topics, or forcing composition before students are ready (Patrick, 2019). So, how can one ensure they are providing proper input? Krashen provides a few ways in his work. Caretakers restrict language to what is most important in the moment, use their desire to be understood, and simplify language (Krashen, 1983). Language teachers must provide support to students to establish clear meaning: visuals, slowing down, repeating, asking yes/no questions, and scaffolding questions (Krashen 1983). If you are thinking that this does not apply to you as a Latin teacher because your goal is not necessarily to get them speaking, you are not alone. Patrick (2019) makes a great note of this and points out that as Latin teachers we also want our students to read and access texts of various literature traditions (Patrick, 2019). 

So, how does this apply to a proper understanding of CI and its inclusion of equity? 

All Day Every Day

This is how you should be applying this principle: all day, every day. The input hypothesis, like them all, applied to language acquisition, but also to everything we do. This principle, in particular, speaks to our disabled students, and our students who work, who are needed for help in the home, or who suffer ACEs, to name a few. So, for today, I am going to do this piece as a list. I am going to do my best to provide resources for each, but you can see my References and Resources list for specific books and sites I've consulted and work with regularly. 
  1. Provide Visuals - This includes everything from visual vocabulary (pictures) to a visual schedule. Provide models, act things out yourself (don't rely on students to act for you), and let students provide visuals to you (see item 5). This will help and support students who are autistic/have ASD, are deaf/hard of hearing, have specific learning disabilities, ESL students, students with speech/language impairments, students who struggle with executive functioning, students with memory concerns, intellectually disabled students, and more. 
  2. Provide Audio - Record yourself reading stories. Record yourself describing images in Latin and English. Record class if you can. Record Dictations. Let students provide you with audio as well (see item 5). This specifically helps blind/vision students, students with processing disorders, students with speech/language impairments, students with ADD/ADHD, and more.
  3. Provide gestures/muscle memory - Our bodies remember things. It is part of what makes triggers so dangerous. Our muscles remember things. It is part of what makes "riding a bike" something you "can't forget". In my class, I use American Sign Language as a way to communicate with and help students communicate with me. You can also use hand created gestures, Total Physical Response (TPR), etc. Let students communicate in this way with you when appropriate. In addition to being a way to ensure understanding without requiring forced output, it is another form of expression (See item 5). This will help serve students with speech/language impairments, who are deaf/hard of hearing, autistic students/students with ASD, students with memory concerns, students with ADD/ADHD, students who are non-verbal, and more. 
  4. Stop saying "it's easy..." - When we say things like this, students feel stupid. If it's easy, why aren't they getting it. If a student fails to understand something in my class, it's likely my fault... in that I didn't provide proper input for them. This is what drives students to say, "I'm no good at language". Further, I often this phrase followed by, "you just need to memorise Y" or "just make some flashcards and review them every night". For our students who work, who struggle with memorisation, who baby-sit their family members, who go home to situations that are dangerous, scary, and more,  these things are not easy. They are, at best, difficult and often impossible. Consider how these words affect your students who do not fit into the affluent, white student mold. Consider how this affects your disabled students who often have to face a label of "being stupid". Consider how this makes your students who suffer ACEs feel.
  5. Provide brain breaks - All of our brains get tired. We all know that feeling. As teachers, especially if we don't see our students first thing, we need to take those breaks. There are a multitude of them out there, but I've provided some in my example below (marked with a green bb) and a link in my resources to some of my favourites. These help serve our kids with ADD/ADHD, intellectually disabled students, students with mental health issues and emotional concerns, students with ACEs, students with executive functioning concerns, and more. 
  6. Provide multiple forms of engagement, representation, and expression. This sums it up. These are the three principles of Universal Design for Learning (UDL). When you consider it, providing CI is providing UDL. In order to provide true CI, you must also provide true UDL. Let's close with a quick example. I will mark various forms of engagement with a red e, representation with a blue r, and expression with a purple x. 

Let's say that I am working with my students on reading some teacher created stories about the Roman gods and goddesses. I have already looked at considerations for vocabulary, culture, triggers, etc. Here is what the first 3 days might look like:
  • Monday - vents and brags, Vocabulary power point (Latin + English + picture E/R, TPR, circling), dragon breath BB, Vocabulary Power Point (dictation E/R), students turn in notes from dictation in translation, note, or drawing format X. 
  • Tuesday - vents and brags, TPR vocabulary review (either with TPR or ASL E, R, X), dictation review (using kids' sentences and pictures from previous day E, R), Would you Rather BB, Task activity E, R
  • Wednesday - vents and brags, Gimkit activity with vocabulary E, R, Story listening of full story (using Latin, English check ins where needed, and images) E, R, The Wave BB, Story Listening E, R, Exit Ticket - What happens next (show in writing, or drawing, X)

References

Cast, Inc. (2020). CAST website. Retrieved from: http://www.cast.org/

Krashen, S. (1983). 
The Natural Approach: Language Acquisition in the Classroom. Alemany Press.

Patrick, M (2020, February 10). Every Day Ideas [Blog]. Retrieved from: 
https://removingbarriers2fl.weebly.com/lists-and-ideas/everyday-accommodations

Patrick, M  (2019, October 1). Quick Assessment Ideas [Blog]. Retrived from: 
https://removingbarriers2fl.weebly.com/lists-and-ideas/quick-assessment-ideas

Patrick, R. (2019). Comprehensible Input and Krashen's theory. 
Journal of Classics Teaching, 20(39), 37-44. doi:10.1017/S2058631019000060
0 Comments

    About

    This particular blog is dedicated to social justice workings in my professional and personal life.

    Archives

    June 2022
    June 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020

    Categories

    All
    ACEs
    Activism
    ASD
    Behaviour
    Black History Month
    Compassion
    Comprehensible Input
    Disability
    Discipline
    Grammar
    Krashen
    Racism
    Special Education
    Strategies

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.