mater monstrorum
  • Home
  • For Teachers
    • Comprehensible Input
    • ESOL >
      • ESOL Activities
      • ESOL Quick links
      • ESOL Reflections
    • Expand Your Classics
    • Online Latin Library
    • PBP/Stepping Into CI >
      • Stepping into CI
      • Pomegranate Beginnings Blog
    • Research
    • Social Emotional Learning
    • Social Justice
    • Special Education >
      • Assistive Technology
      • Implementation
    • Technology >
      • Audio and Video Resources
      • Digital Classroom
  • For Students
    • Online Latin Library
    • Take a Class
    • Tutoring
  • Originals
    • Lesson Plans
    • Original Audio Stories
    • Original Characters
    • Original Songs
    • Pondering Petronius
  • Publications
    • Published Novellas
    • Professional Publications
    • Presentations
  • Announcements
  • About me
    • Contact
  • Home
  • For Teachers
    • Comprehensible Input
    • ESOL >
      • ESOL Activities
      • ESOL Quick links
      • ESOL Reflections
    • Expand Your Classics
    • Online Latin Library
    • PBP/Stepping Into CI >
      • Stepping into CI
      • Pomegranate Beginnings Blog
    • Research
    • Social Emotional Learning
    • Social Justice
    • Special Education >
      • Assistive Technology
      • Implementation
    • Technology >
      • Audio and Video Resources
      • Digital Classroom
  • For Students
    • Online Latin Library
    • Take a Class
    • Tutoring
  • Originals
    • Lesson Plans
    • Original Audio Stories
    • Original Characters
    • Original Songs
    • Pondering Petronius
  • Publications
    • Published Novellas
    • Professional Publications
    • Presentations
  • Announcements
  • About me
    • Contact
Books to Read
Resources for Action
Blogs and Articles to Read
Social Media to Follow
Audio to Listen to and Videos to watch

Comprehensible Input and Social Justice (1)

6/24/2020

0 Comments

 
This post is a long time coming. I want to be clear in that. Over the past year or so it has popped up throughout a variety of forums and in a number of ways. Many say that no single teaching "method" is inherently equitable... and I agree with that. However, I disagree that Comprehensible Input is a teaching method. It is a philosophy and hypothesis. Today I want to (quickly I hope) break down the six pieces and how they relate to social justice. This is not meant to be an exhaustive piece. This may turn into a much larger series of posts, but for now, let's get into it.

EDIT: As I started writing, I realised this is going to be MUCH longer than I anticipated.... So, it will be a series of 6 posts. Today's is on the first principle of Comprehensible Input: Acquisition and Learning.

Acquisition and Learning

This may be the most well known piece of the Comprehension Hypothesis. It states that language acquisition happens subconsciously when one understands the messages one receives in the target language, whether through reading or listening (Krashen, 2012). Learning refers to the explicit teaching and learning about a language: its gears and parts (Patrick, 2019).  With acquisition, we are not aware of the processes happening inside our brain. With learning, we are. 

The idea has been stated recently that because of this distinction, the use of CI in the classroom is actually racist on the premise that CI teachers are "dumbing down" content for BIPOC. However, this argument is built on a misunderstanding of CI principles. Nowhere in the hypothesis does it say that learning does not have a place in the classroom. What it says is that learning does not help language acquisition. When students are ready, CI teachers will employ the use of explicit learning language strategies to help them further their skills and make use of their inner monitor. The key piece, however, is when students are ready. This speaks to this principle's purpose in a culturally responsive and social justice aware classroom. Rather than holding students (any student) to a standard decided upon by adults, students get to communicate their level of comfort and readiness for explicit learning topics. They are part of the conversation. They have a voice. This is not a "dumbing down" of content, but a restructuring. 

I'd like, bearing in mind that I do not want these posts to be miles long, to suggest some ways practical and real ways that this principle, when applied correctly, is socially justice minded and culturally aware. 
  1. Memorisation of charts - This discussion of inclusion of disabled students in the classroom is a major one and there is not enough space here for me to go into all the details; they will be included in each piece explicitly. I'm going to put this out there. The use of charts with the requirement of memorisation of said charts (especially when used on assessments) is ableist. Charts in and of themselves are not. However, there are a number of disabilities that make such things as memorization difficult and when you make that a core tenant of how students are evaluated, you are closing the door and conversation for a number of students. CI, when employed directly, allows the brain to relax to some extent and enjoy the language. Students can make progress. When students are ready, we can provide charts as a resource. 
  2. Memorisation of vocabulary - Another piece to this. This is one of the top things I hear when a disabled student says they are afraid of language class. They say things like, "I'm just no good at memorising" or "I can't remember vocabulary". The proper use of CI takes away this sense of "memorisation requirement" and puts the work back on the teacher. If a student cannot remember a vocabulary word, what am I doing to support them and help them get more CI. Language acquisition is a subconscious process. Memorisation is not. 
  3. Comprehensible... No, really - Comprehensible means understood. It doesn't mean, oh, once I've figured out the context of a thing, I get it. Comprehensible in on the teacher. In our classrooms, in order for things to truly be comprehensible, we must be culturally and racially aware and responsive. As teachers who employ the principles of CI we must always be considering how comprehensible something truly is, from many angles. On the one hand, yes, simple English equivalent is the first piece. You will have some students in your classroom who struggle to understand abstract concepts. It is key to this principle that you make even the English comprehensible. You will also have students for whom English is not their first or most comfortable language. What work are you doing to ensure that something is truly comprehensible for them? Some vocabulary words/ideas/concepts are things that speak to racism, affluence, etc. How are you working to ensure that these terms are comprehensible to all in your classroom AND do not further ideas of racism and elitism? These are ALL key pieces to this principle. 
These are just three examples. This list is incomplete. I would love to see in the comments more. If needed, I can make another post on more. 

So, I'd like to close today's post with this. If you, as a teacher, are not ensuring that your content is truly comprehensible to your students in the multitude of ways it can be, you are missing some key points about this principle of the Comprehension Hypothesis. There is work to be done. In order to use the Comprehension Hypothesis and be a "CI teacher" you do not have to be perfect. I am not perfect. You do, however, have to do the work. This is the first part of the work. 

References

Krashen, S. (2012). The comprehension hypothesis extended. Input Matters in SLA. Bristol: Multilingual Matters, 81-94. Retrieved from: 
​
http://sdkrashen.com/content/articles/comprehension_hypothesis_extended.pdf

Patrick, R. (2019). Comprehensible Input and Krashen's theory. 
Journal of Classics Teaching, 20(39), 37-44. doi:10.1017/S2058631019000060
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    About

    This particular blog is dedicated to social justice workings in my professional and personal life.

    Archives

    June 2022
    June 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020

    Categories

    All
    ACEs
    Activism
    ASD
    Behaviour
    Black History Month
    Compassion
    Comprehensible Input
    Disability
    Discipline
    Grammar
    Krashen
    Racism
    Special Education
    Strategies

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly